Combined loading

Introduction to Combined Loading

In the real world, mechanical components rarely experience a single type of load at a time. Instead, components such as shafts, beams, and columns often carry multiple kinds of forces simultaneously. This simultaneous action leads to composite stresses, affecting their strength and durability. Understanding combined loading is essential for designing safe and efficient mechanical systems, as it allows engineers to calculate the actual stresses that develop from the sum of different loadings.

Imagine a rotating shaft like those used in vehicle drive trains or industrial machines-while it transmits torque (causing torsion), it may also support bending forces from attached elements and axial forces from thrust loads. Ignoring any one of these loads could lead to underestimating stresses, resulting in premature failure.

This section explains how to analyze such combined effects by breaking down stresses into basic components and then recombining them logically to predict the worst-case stress scenario. This approach ensures components meet safety requirements and perform reliably under complex service conditions.

Stress Components in Combined Loading

Before delving into combined loading, let's recall the basic stress types:

Normal stress (\( \sigma \)): Acts perpendicular to a surface, caused by axial loads or bending moments. It can be tensile (stretching) or compressive (squeezing).
Shear stress (\( \tau \)): Acts parallel to a surface, mainly caused by torsion or transverse shear forces.

When a member is subjected to combined loading, these stresses act together at points in the material. The principle of superposition allows us to add the effects from individual loading types to find the overall stress. This is valid when materials behave elastically and loads do not exceed yield limits.

The diagram above illustrates a circular shaft segment subjected simultaneously to:

An axial load (P) that creates a uniform normal stress over the cross section.
A bending moment (M) that induces a normal stress varying linearly across the cross section, tensile on one side and compressive on the other.
A torque (T) that produces shear stress distributed over the cross section, maximum at the outer surface.

At a point on the shaft, these stress components combine, affecting the material's safety and service life. Understanding how to calculate and combine them is the next step.

Calculation of Combined Stresses

To find the combined stresses at any critical point on a member under axial, bending, and torsional loads, follow a systematic approach:

graph TD  A[Identify all external loads on the member] --> B[Calculate normal stress due to axial load: \sigma_{axial} = P/A]  B --> C[Calculate bending stress: \sigma_{bending} = \pm My/I]  C --> D[Calculate shear stress due to torsion: \tau = Tc/J]  D --> E[Use superposition to combine stresses]  E --> F[Calculate principal stresses using formulas or Mohr's circle]  F --> G[Compare with allowable stresses and factor of safety]

Here is the detailed explanation of each calculation:

Normal normal stress from axial load: Given axial load \(P\) and cross-sectional area \(A\), the uniform normal stress is \( \sigma_{axial} = \frac{P}{A} \). This is tensile if the load pulls, compressive if it pushes.
Normal stress due to bending moment: The bending moment \(M\) causes normal stresses varying linearly with distance \(y\) from the neutral axis. This is calculated as \( \sigma_{bending} = \frac{M y}{I} \), where \(I\) is the moment of inertia of the cross-section.
Shear stress from torsion: Torsion applies a shear stress \( \tau = \frac{Tc}{J} \) where \(T\) is torque, \(c\) is outer radius and \(J\) is polar moment of inertia.
Superposition: Since these stresses arise from independent loadings, the total normal stress at point \(y\) is \( \sigma = \sigma_{axial} \pm \sigma_{bending} \), and the shear stress remains \( \tau \) from torsion.
Principal stresses and maximum shear: To fully understand the combined stress state, calculate principal stresses using the formulas involving combined normal and shear stresses, or visually using Mohr's circle.

This layered approach helps to break down a complex loading scenario into manageable calculations, increasing confidence and accuracy in design.

Key Concept

Superposition Principle

Stresses from individual loads can be calculated separately and algebraically added for combined loading analysis.

Formula Bank

Normal Stress due to Axial and Bending

\[\sigma = \frac{P}{A} \pm \frac{M y}{I}\]

where: \(P\) = axial load (N), \(A\) = cross-sectional area (m²), \(M\) = bending moment (Nm), \(y\) = distance from neutral axis (m), \(I\) = moment of inertia (m⁴)

Shear Stress due to Torsion

\[\tau = \frac{T c}{J}\]

where: \(T\) = torque (Nm), \(c\) = outer radius (m), \(J\) = polar moment of inertia (m⁴)

Polar Moment of Inertia for Solid Circular Shaft

\[J = \frac{\pi d^{4}}{32}\]

where: \(d\) = diameter of shaft (m)

Principal Stresses for Combined Loading

\[\sigma_{1,2} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2}\]

where: \(\sigma_x, \sigma_y\) = normal stresses (Pa), \(\tau_{xy}\) = shear stress (Pa)

Maximum Shear Stress

\[\tau_{max} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2}\]

Same as above

Worked Examples

Example 1: Combined Axial and Bending Stress in a Beam Medium

A steel beam of rectangular cross section 150 mm wide and 300 mm deep carries an axial compressive load of 80 kN and a bending moment of 12 kNm. Calculate the maximum normal stress in the beam. Take neutral axis at mid-depth and modulus of elasticity irrelevant here.

Step 1: Calculate cross-sectional area \(A\):

\(A = 0.15 \, m \times 0.3 \, m = 0.045 \, m^2\)

Step 2: Find normal stress from axial load \(P = 80,000\, N\):

\(\sigma_{axial} = \frac{P}{A} = \frac{80,000}{0.045} = 1,777,778 \, Pa = 1.78 \, MPa\) (compressive)

Step 3: Calculate moment of inertia \(I\) for rectangular section:

\(I = \frac{b d^3}{12} = \frac{0.15 \times (0.3)^3}{12} = 3.375 \times 10^{-4} \, m^4\)

Step 4: Determine distance from neutral axis to extreme fiber \(y = \frac{d}{2} = 0.15 \, m\)

Step 5: Calculate bending stress:

\(\sigma_{bending} = \frac{M y}{I} = \frac{12,000 \times 0.15}{3.375 \times 10^{-4}} = 5,333,333 \, Pa = 5.33\, MPa\)

Step 6: Since axial load is compressive, and bending causes tensile on one side and compressive on the other, combine accordingly:

Maximum compressive stress = \(1.78 + 5.33 = 7.11 \, MPa\)

Maximum tensile stress = \(5.33 - 1.78 = 3.55 \, MPa\)

Answer: Maximum compressive stress is 7.11 MPa, and maximum tensile stress is 3.55 MPa in the beam.

Example 2: Shear and Normal Stress in a Torsionally Loaded Shaft Medium

A solid circular shaft of diameter 50 mm is subjected to an axial tensile load of 20 kN and a torque of 400 Nm. Determine the axial stress, shear stress due to torsion, and estimate the combined stresses at the outer surface. Also, estimate the cost of the steel material required for 1 m length of the shaft if the cost of steel is INR 60 per kg. Density of steel is 7850 kg/m³.

Step 1: Calculate cross-sectional area \(A\):

\(d = 0.05\, m\)

\(A = \frac{\pi d^2}{4} = \frac{\pi (0.05)^2}{4} = 1.9635 \times 10^{-3} \, m^2\)

Step 2: Axial normal stress:

\(\sigma_{axial} = \frac{P}{A} = \frac{20,000}{1.9635 \times 10^{-3}} = 10.19 \times 10^6 \, Pa = 10.19 \, MPa\)

Step 3: Calculate polar moment of inertia \(J\):

\[J = \frac{\pi d^4}{32} = \frac{\pi (0.05)^4}{32} = 3.07 \times 10^{-7} \, m^4\]

Step 4: Calculate shear stress due to torque:

Radius \(c = \frac{d}{2} = 0.025\, m\)

\(\tau = \frac{T c}{J} = \frac{400 \times 0.025}{3.07 \times 10^{-7}} = 32.56 \times 10^{6} \, Pa = 32.56 \, MPa\)

Step 5: Combined stress state at surface:

Normal stress \(\sigma_x = 10.19 \, MPa\)

Shear stress \(\tau_{xy} = 32.56 \, MPa\)

Step 6: Calculate principal stresses:

\[ \sigma_{1,2} = \frac{10.19 + 0}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{10.19 - 0}{2}\right)^2 + (32.56)^2} \]

\[ = 5.095 \pm \sqrt{(5.095)^2 + (32.56)^2} = 5.095 \pm 32.97 \]

\(\sigma_1 = 38.07\, MPa\), \(\sigma_2 = -27.88\, MPa\) (compression)

Step 7: Estimate volume and weight of 1m shaft:

\(V = A \times L = 1.9635 \times 10^{-3} \times 1 = 1.9635 \times 10^{-3} \, m^3\)

Mass \(m = \rho V = 7850 \times 1.9635 \times 10^{-3} = 15.41\, kg\)

Step 8: Cost estimation:

\(Cost = 15.41 \times 60 = \text{INR }924.6\)

Answer: Axial stress = 10.19 MPa, shear stress = 32.56 MPa, principal stresses = 38.07 MPa (max) and -27.88 MPa (min). Material cost for 1m shaft ≈ INR 925.

Example 3: Principal Stress Calculation for Combined Loading Hard

A steel plate is subjected to a bending stress of 50 MPa tensile and an axial compressive stress of 30 MPa. The plate also experiences a shear stress of 40 MPa. Calculate the principal stresses and the orientation of the principal planes.

Step 1: Identify stresses:

Let \(\sigma_x = 50 \, MPa\) (tensile), \(\sigma_y = -30 \, MPa\) (compressive), and \(\tau_{xy}=40 \, MPa\)

Step 2: Calculate average stress:

\[ \sigma_{avg} = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} = \frac{50 - 30}{2} = 10 \, MPa \]

Step 3: Calculate radius for Mohr's circle:

\[ R = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\right)^2 + \tau_{xy}^2} = \sqrt{(40)^2 + (40)^2} = \sqrt{1600 + 1600} = \sqrt{3200} = 56.57 \, MPa \]

Step 4: Find principal stresses:

\[ \sigma_1 = \sigma_{avg} + R = 10 + 56.57 = 66.57 \, MPa \]

\[ \sigma_2 = \sigma_{avg} - R = 10 - 56.57 = -46.57 \, MPa \]

Step 5: Calculate the angle \(\theta_p\) for principal plane orientations:

\[ \tan 2\theta_p = \frac{2 \tau_{xy}}{\sigma_x - \sigma_y} = \frac{2 \times 40}{50 - (-30)} = \frac{80}{80} = 1 \]

\(\Rightarrow 2 \theta_p = 45^\circ \Rightarrow \theta_p = 22.5^\circ\)

Answer: Principal stresses are 66.57 MPa (tensile) and -46.57 MPa (compressive). Principal planes are oriented at 22.5° to the original plane.

Example 4: Design of a Shaft under Combined Bending and Torsion Hard

Design the diameter of a solid circular shaft required to transmit 20 kW power at 1200 rpm. The shaft is subjected to a bending moment of 800 Nm and a torque due to transmitted power. Use a factor of safety of 2. The material's yield strength in shear is 300 MPa. Use maximum shear stress theory for design.

Step 1: Calculate torque \(T\) from power and speed:

Power \(P = 20 \, kW = 20,000\, W\)

Speed \(N = 1200\, rpm\)

\[ T = \frac{P \times 60}{2 \pi N} = \frac{20,000 \times 60}{2 \pi \times 1200} = \frac{1,200,000}{7,539.8} \approx 159.2 \, Nm \]

Step 2: Calculate design shear stress:

Allowable shear stress with factor of safety:

\[ \tau_{allow} = \frac{300}{2} = 150 \, MPa \]

Step 3: Let diameter be \(d\), polar moment of inertia \(J = \frac{\pi d^4}{32}\), bending moment \(M=800\, Nm\), torque \(T=159.2\, Nm\).

Step 4: Calculate bending stress at outer fiber:

\[ \sigma_b = \frac{32 M}{\pi d^{3}} \]

Step 5: Calculate shear stress due to torsion:

\[ \tau = \frac{16 T}{\pi d^{3}} \]

Step 6: Using maximum shear stress theory:

Maximum shear stress in the shaft is:

\[ \tau_{max} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_b}{2}\right)^2 + \tau^2} \]

Step 7: Substitute and equate to allowable shear stress:

\[ 150 = \sqrt{\left(\frac{32 M}{2 \pi d^3}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{16 T}{\pi d^3}\right)^2} = \frac{16}{\pi d^3} \sqrt{\left( M \right)^2 + (T)^2} \]

Step 8: Calculate numerator under the root:

\[ \sqrt{(800)^2 + (159.2)^2} = \sqrt{640,000 + 25,344} = \sqrt{665,344} = 815.7\, Nm \]

Step 9: Rearrange for \(d\):

\[ 150 = \frac{16 \times 815.7}{\pi d^3} \Rightarrow d^3 = \frac{16 \times 815.7}{\pi \times 150} = \frac{13,051}{471.24} = 27.71 \]

Step 10: Calculate \(d\):

\(d = \sqrt[3]{27.71} = 3.02\, cm = 30.2\, mm\)

Answer: The required diameter of the shaft is approximately 30.2 mm.

Example 5: Estimate Maximum Shear Stress Using Mohr's Circle Medium

A flat steel plate is subjected to normal stresses \(\sigma_x = 40\, MPa\) tensile, \(\sigma_y = 10\, MPa\) compressive and a shear stress \(\tau_{xy} = 25\, MPa\). Use Mohr's circle to determine the maximum shear stress.

Step 1: Calculate average normal stress:

\[ \sigma_{avg} = \frac{40 + (-10)}{2} = 15 \, MPa \]

Step 2: Compute radius of Mohr's circle (maximum shear):

\[ \tau_{max} = \sqrt{\left(\frac{40 - (-10)}{2}\right)^2 + 25^2} = \sqrt{25^2 + 25^2} = \sqrt{625 + 625} = \sqrt{1250} = 35.36 \, MPa \]

Answer: The maximum shear stress in the plate is 35.36 MPa as shown by Mohr's circle.

Combined Normal Stress

\[\sigma = \frac{P}{A} \pm \frac{My}{I}\]

Calculates normal stress under axial and bending loads

P = Axial load (N)

A = Cross-sectional area (m²)

M = Bending moment (Nm)

y = Distance from neutral axis (m)

I = Moment of inertia (m⁴)

Key Concept

Factor of Safety in Combined Loading

Design stresses must be within yield limits divided by factor of safety to prevent failure.

Tips & Tricks

Tip: Always draw free body diagrams showing each load separately.

When to use: To avoid confusion and correctly identify individual effects in combined loading.

Tip: Use superposition to add axial and bending normal stresses algebraically before combining with shear stress.

When to use: When dealing with combined axial and bending loads on beams and shafts.

Tip: The maximum bending stress occurs at the extreme fibers-at maximum distance from the neutral axis.

When to use: While calculating bending and combined stresses on beams.

Tip: Use Mohr's circle to visualize and accurately calculate principal and maximum shear stresses.

When to use: Complex combined stress scenarios involving both normal and shear stresses.

Tip: Convert all units to SI standard units before performing calculations to avoid errors.

When to use: Always, especially during exams and design tasks.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

❌ Confusing location of maximum bending stress; using incorrect \(y\) value.

✓ Always take \(y\) as the maximum distance from the neutral axis (extreme fiber) where stress is calculated.

Why: Using average or incorrect \(y\) under time pressure causes underestimation of bending stress.

❌ Adding shear stress and normal stress directly without considering their vector nature.

✓ Use principal stress formulas or Mohr's circle to combine stresses properly, since normal and shear stresses act differently.

Why: Scalar addition ignores stress directions leading to incorrect stress magnitudes.

❌ Using diameter instead of radius in the polar moment of inertia formula or in shear stress calculations.

✓ Use the correct formula: \(J = \frac{\pi d^4}{32}\) for solid shafts and \(c = \frac{d}{2}\) as radius for shear stress.

Why: Confusing radius and diameter can cause errors by a factor of 2 or more.

❌ Ignoring sign conventions for axial loads and bending moments.

✓ Follow standard sign conventions: tensile positive, compressive negative; sagging moments positive, hogging negative.

Why: Incorrect signs cause wrong stress calculations, resulting in unsafe designs.

❌ Forgetting to apply factor of safety in design calculations.

✓ Always apply appropriate factor of safety based on IS codes and material properties.

Why: Ensures safety margins against uncertainties and actual operating conditions.

The Joy of Learning

Login

The Joy of Learning

Sign-up

The Joy of Learning

Forgot Password

Introduction to Combined Loading

Stress Components in Combined Loading

Calculation of Combined Stresses

Superposition Principle

Formula Bank

Formula Bank

Worked Examples

Combined Normal Stress

Factor of Safety in Combined Loading

Tips & Tricks

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Try Practice next.

Rank

eBook

Online Test Series + eBook

Book is added to your cart!